Menu of Norma Jean's Ice Cream in Borden, Indiana, USA

Menu Overview

Norma Jean's Ice Cream, nestled in the heart of Borden, Indiana, is a charming small-town gem that delivers much more than just ice cream. This quaint shop at 302 E Water St blends old-fashioned charm with a diverse menu that satisfies both savory and sweet cravings. From the moment you arrive, the warm atmosphere and friendly staff invite you to settle in and enjoy a truly memorable dining experience.

The menu boasts an impressive variety, making it a versatile destination for families and ice cream lovers alike. While known primarily for their rich and creamy ice cream treats, including standouts like the Ultimate Oreo Cookie Dough and the refreshingly smooth Pineapple Milkshake, Norma Jean's also serves hearty fare that complements the sweets perfectly. The Chili Cheese Dog and classic Hot Dog and Fries offer satisfying, savory options, showcasing the shop’s ability to deliver comfort food alongside decadent desserts.

The ice cream specialties truly steal the show. The Fat Elvis — a tribute to the King himself — blends flavors in a nostalgic yet inventive way, while the Strawberry Banana Split lives up to its generous reputation, the kind of classic treat that demands more than one sitting or sharing with a friend. The Apple Dumpling a La Mode highlights their skillful craftsmanship, pairing warm pastry with creamy ice cream in a way that evokes both comfort and indulgence. For chocolate lovers, the Hot Fudge Brownie is a luscious, rich dessert that promises a perfect balance of warmth and sweetness.

What elevates Norma Jean’s experience is not just the food and dessert but the environment and service. Visitors like Jeff Jarecki praise the spotless outdoor seating area overlooking a gentle stream, where families can relax and enjoy nature while indulging in their treats. The staff's genuine friendliness and attentiveness, along with thoughtful gestures such as offering to split scoops for those wanting to sample multiple flavors, create an inviting atmosphere that feels like home.

Prices are reasonable, reflecting generous portions and quality. Mark Blackburn’s review of the banana split underscores this value—it’s enough for two to share comfortably, which is rare among similar establishments. Additionally, the shop caters to pet owners with complimentary doggy cups, enhancing the welcoming vibe for all visitors.

Norma Jean's Ice Cream is a shining example of a small-town ice cream shop done right: a harmonious blend of delightful treats, savory classics, attentive service, and a cozy setting by the water. Whether you crave a classic soft serve, a bold Oreo concoction, or a satisfying chili cheese dog, this spot promises a rich culinary experience that leaves you wanting to return season after season.